2 Marriage Lessons 'Indian Matchmaking' Can Teach Us

For many people, 'dating burnout' is a real, pressing issue. Here's what 'Indian Matchmaking' can teach us about minimizing the fatigue.

By Mark Travers, Ph.D. | April 24, 2025

As more individuals experience dating burnout and exhaustion from dating apps, many are turning away from the endless swiping in search of something more meaningful. This may be why more and more people are opening up to the idea of their parents and other community members helping them seek lifelong partners. This is where practices like arranged marriages and matchmaking come into play.

Arranged marriages are unions where families, matchmakers or community elders play a significant role in selecting a spouse, often based on compatibility in values, background and long-term goals.

This system is common in cultures across South Asia, the Middle East and even among some Western communities seeking alternatives to algorithm-driven dating. While traditionally rooted in familial and social ties, contemporary arranged marriages now blend tradition with personal choice — making them more of a curated introduction than an imposed decision.

Shows like Netflix's Indian Matchmaking, though controversial, shed some light on how many still find comfort in structured approaches to love — offering valuable insights into what really matters in building a lasting marriage.

Here are two key lessons we can take away from matchmaking practices.

1. Prioritize Compatibility Over Chemistry

Many viewers have been critical of Sima Taparia, the matchmaker from Indian Matchmaking, who became notorious for advising compromise in the search for a partner. And while no one should ever settle for someone that's not right for them, her emphasis on practicality over passion points to something many modern daters overlook: the difference between initial spark and long-term sustainability.

At its core, matchmaking often prioritizes shared values, long-term goals and emotional compatibility over fleeting attraction. It asks a deeper question: Can you build a life with this person? Not just "Do you have butterflies right now?"

While mainstream Western dating culture often chases the high of instant chemistry, long-term relationship satisfaction hinges more on factors like mutual respect, emotional intelligence and aligned life visions than raw attraction. That's not to say chemistry doesn't matter — but in arranged setups, it's viewed as something that can grow over time, rather than the starting point.

Some individuals are content to build love with the person they marry, while others chase the elusive spark with someone they've just met. But in the end, it's often the slow burn — not instant chemistry — that sustains a marriage.

Research shows that in successful arranged marriages, love tends to grow over time, largely due to the couple's commitment to each other. This love is often rooted in shared experiences, mutual respect and a willingness to grow together.

This commitment often gives couples the resilience to adopt a "work it out" mindset, learning to resolve conflicts rather than walking away at the first sign of trouble. Researchers suggest that similar approaches — involving patience, loyalty and commitment — could help sustain love in Western marriages, where, according to research trends, it tends to fade over time.

2. Community Support Is Important

In Western cultures, we often glorify the idea of romantic love as a deeply private, individual journey — something that should happen spontaneously, without interference. But matchmaking practices remind us that having the support of family and community can actually enhance a couple's ability to thrive, especially when that involvement is balanced and respectful.

In the U.S., many Indian-American couples in arranged marriages report feeling supported, not pressured, by their families. A study published in The Family Journal shows that they enjoy the stability of arranged marriages, but experience fewer family pressures compared to their counterparts in India. For Indians in arranged marriages living in India, those who had more say in choosing their spouse reported higher satisfaction.

Interestingly, researchers also found that Indian-American couples tend to form stronger marital bonds when they live away from extended family. Being physically distanced from parental oversight can allow partners to become more interdependent and united in their decision-making — all while still drawing strength from their cultural roots.

Such individuals likely experience the benefits of community involvement — such as emotional backing, cultural continuity and guidance.

This balance between tradition and autonomy offers an important lesson: strong marriages don't necessarily develop in a vacuum. While too much outside influence can be stifling, completely isolating a couple from community input can be just as risky. Having a circle of trusted people — whether that's family, mentors or cultural community — can provide perspective, emotional reinforcement and even accountability when times get tough.

For many U.S. couples, especially those who feel burned out by hyper-individualized dating culture, looking to family or community for support in choosing or sustaining a relationship might feel unfamiliar — but it's not outdated. It's simply another way of rooting love in something larger than just two people.

A Sense Of Agency Is Key In Any Marriage

For years, in many traditional arranged marriage set-ups, communities may have prioritized fulfilling societal checklists over individual happiness.

Sons and daughters were often married off based on criteria such as financial stability for men and domestic skills like cooking and cleaning for women, leaving little room for personal choice. Many individuals may have preferred to remain happily single rather than enter such unions.

Families today are increasingly recognizing that their children's priorities have evolved. Partner selection now involves deeper considerations. Moreover, the success of a marriage often depends on how much autonomy an individual has in choosing their partner.

A 2019 study published in the International Journal of Psychology shows that people who exercised greater influence in selecting their spouse reported higher levels of intimacy, passion, commitment and overall marital satisfaction.

This could stem from the simple truth that when both partners know they chose each other — freely and willingly — it encourages deeper love, commitment and mutual appreciation. In the end, no matter how you meet your spouse, what truly matters is that you both feel empowered in your decision.

Is your relationship simply happy, or is it truly thriving? Take this test to find out: Relationship Flourishing Scale

A similar version of this article can also be found on Forbes.com, here.